5 Best Gym Debt Collection Companies – Ranked & Reviewed for Gym Owners

Compare the best gym debt collection companies like First Credit Services (FCS), Summit A•R, Southwest Recovery Services (SWRS), MetCredit, and DebtCo.

Managing unpaid gym memberships is a significant challenge for fitness business owners. Late payments and delinquent accounts can disrupt cash flow, strain member relationships, and consume valuable administrative time. While partnering with a reputable debt collection agency can help recover lost revenue, integrating a robust gym management system like Exercise.com can proactively reduce delinquencies and streamline operations.

Company	Industry Experience	Recovery Rate	Fee Structure	Member Approach	Integration Capabilities	Gym Brand Preservation
First Credit Services (FCS)	25+ years, largest fitness industry collector	30-40%	Contingency (25-45% of recovered funds)	“Member-centric” with escalating contact strategies	Limited API integration with select platforms	Moderate – uses own branding in communications
Summit A•R	25+ years in fitness industry	Claims 2x industry average (40-50%)	Contingency (30-50% of recovered funds)	“P.H.D. Philosophy” (Preserve Human Dignity)	Manual file uploads, limited automation	High – focuses on respectful recovery
Southwest Recovery Services (SWRS)	15+ years specialized in fitness	25-35%	Tiered contingency (higher for older accounts)	Emphasis on flexible payment options	Minimal integration, primarily manual processes	Moderate – attempts reactivation before collection
MetCredit	40+ years, serves Canadian market	30-40%	Contingency with performance tiers	“Solution-Oriented Recovery” approach	Limited API capabilities with major platforms	Moderate – emphasizes ethical collection
DebtCo	10+ years in fitness sector	20-30% for collections, higher for reactivation	Two-phase model with reactivation commission	Reactivation-first approach with collection as last resort	Basic file transfer, minimal automation	High – specializes in brand-aligned communication
Exercise.com	Not a collection agency – gym software platform	Reduces accounts needing collection	Subscription software	Prevention-focused system with automated retention tools	Comprehensive integration with all business systems	Maximum – prevents collection scenarios while maintaining positive relationships

Note: Recovery rates and fee structures are industry averages based on publicly available information and may vary based on specific agreements and account types.

Get a demo now!

#1 Exercise.com (Gym Software Platform)

Exercise.com is not a debt collection agency but rather a comprehensive gym management platform that dramatically reduces the need for collection services through proactive payment management and gym member retention strategies.

Pros

• Helps prevent delinquent accounts through intelligent payment processing like smart retries and automatic card updater technology
• Maintains positive member relationships through service-oriented communication
• Seamlessly integrates payment processing, member management, and retention tools
• Provides comprehensive analytics on payment performance and revenue capture
• Software subscription model

Cons

• Not a solution for existing severely delinquent accounts
• Requires implementation before payment issues occur for maximum effectiveness

As the best gym payment processing software available, Exercise.com addresses the root causes of payment delinquency rather than treating the symptoms. The platform’s intelligent retry logic automatically attempts declined payments at optimal times based on card type, bank, and member payment history. This approach recovers more failed payments than standard processing systems, directly improving cash flow without negative member interactions.

The system includes specialized tools for payment method updating, allowing members to conveniently update expired or replaced cards through text, email, or app interfaces. This self-service approach maintains member dignity while significantly reducing administrative burden on staff.

For gym operators seeking to maximize revenue capture while preserving member relationships, Exercise.com’s best gym point of sale (POS) system software provides front desk staff with real-time payment status information, creating organic opportunities to resolve issues during regular visits. This approach aligns perfectly with proven strategies for how to increase gym membership retention by addressing financial matters within the context of the overall member experience.

#2 First Credit Services (FCS)

First Credit Services positions itself as the largest provider of collections specifically for the health and fitness industry, with particular expertise in recovering unpaid gym membership debt collection accounts.

Pros

• Extensive fitness industry experience with major brands including Crunch Fitness
• Multiple contact strategies including phone, mail, text, and email
• Higher than average recovery rates for recent delinquencies (first 90 days)
• Some integration capabilities with major management platforms
• Compliance management systems for varying state regulations

Cons

• Higher fee structure compared to general collection agencies
• Member-facing collections can damage gym brand perception
• Limited effectiveness for long-term delinquent accounts

First Credit Services has established itself as a dominant player in the gym debt collection space through partnerships with major fitness brands. Their First Credit Services Crunch Fitness relationship demonstrates their ability to handle high-volume collection needs for multi-location operators. The company claims to differentiate through a “member-centric” approach that attempts to maintain positive relationships despite the inherently adversarial nature of collections.

Their recovery strategy employs a graduated contact approach that begins with gentle reminders and escalates based on account age and response patterns. The First Credit Services phone number appears on member caller ID during outreach attempts, which creates immediate brand association challenges for gym operators despite compliance with legal requirements. While their recovery rates exceed industry averages, the contingency fee structure (typically 25-45% of recovered funds) significantly reduces the net financial benefit to gym operators.

For gyms experiencing high volumes of delinquent accounts, FCS offers batch processing capabilities that reduce operational complexity. However, the superior approach remains implementing a preventative system like Exercise.com’s best gym management software, which addresses payment issues before external collections become necessary, preserving both revenue and member relationships.

Website: First Credit Services (FCS)

#3 Summit A•R

Summit A•R has positioned itself as a more ethical alternative in the debt collector gym membership space, emphasizing their “P.H.D. Philosophy” (Preserve Human Dignity) approach to collections.

Pros

• Claims recovery rates nearly double the industry average
• Emphasizes ethical, dignified collection practices
• No aggressive or harassing tactics that reflect poorly on gym brands
• Reports to credit bureaus only as a last resort
• Transparent online portal for tracking collection status

Cons

• Higher fees for their specialized approach (typically 30-50%)
• Limited integration capabilities with gym management systems
• Manual account submission processes create operational inefficiency

Summit A•R has carved out a niche in the health club debt collection agency landscape by focusing on recovery methods that minimize negative impacts on the gym’s brand reputation. Their approach begins with professional, non-threatening communication that assumes payment issues result from oversight or temporary hardship rather than deliberate avoidance. This philosophy aligns with the relationship-focused approach that successful gyms value.

Their recovery strategy employs a combination of phone and written communication, with emphasis on finding workable solutions for members facing financial challenges. While the company reports recovery rates significantly above industry averages, the higher fee structure reflects the more labor-intensive approach to collections. For gym operators sensitive to brand perception, these higher fees may represent a worthwhile investment compared to more aggressive collection alternatives.

Despite their more member-friendly approach, Summit A•R still represents an external collections process that occurs after the damage to the member relationship has begun. Exercise.com’s preventative approach through its best personal training software and payment management systems creates a superior alternative by addressing payment issues within the context of ongoing service delivery, dramatically reducing the need for external collections while preserving valuable member relationships.

Website: Summit A•R

#4 Southwest Recovery Services (SWRS)

Southwest Recovery Services specializes in the fitness industry with an approach that attempts to bridge the gap between member retention and traditional collections for gym debt.

Pros

• Specialized fitness industry expertise and understanding
• Emphasis on flexible payment arrangements
• Online payment portal for convenient resolution
• Attempts member reactivation before pure collection
• Regional expertise particularly in southern states

Cons

• Limited technology integration with management systems
• Tiered fee structure that increases with account age
• Lower overall recovery rates compared to larger agencies

SWRS has developed a hybrid approach to fitness collections that begins with member reengagement attempts before transitioning to more traditional collection activities. Their strategy focuses on understanding the unique relationship dynamics between fitness facilities and their members, recognizing that many delinquent accounts result from service dissatisfaction rather than inability to pay. This nuanced approach has proven effective for gyms with member bases that include substantial proportions of first-time fitness consumers.

Their collection protocol includes both traditional communication methods and digital engagement options, including an online payment portal that facilitates convenient resolution. The company employs a tiered contingency fee structure that escalates based on account age, incentivizing rapid resolution while reflecting the decreasing likelihood of recovery over time. For smaller regional gym operators, their personalized service approach can provide advantages over larger collection factories.

While SWRS offers a more retention-focused collection approach than many competitors, their services still represent a reactive response to payment issues rather than a preventative solution. Exercise.com’s integrated platform addresses this by providing comprehensive gym collections prevention through intelligent payment processing, automated communication, and staff empowerment tools that resolve issues before they require external intervention.

Website: Southwest Recovery Services (SWRS)

#5 MetCredit

MetCredit provides collection services across Canada with particular expertise in the fitness industry and a focus on ethical recovery practices.

Pros

• Comprehensive coverage across Canadian provinces
• “Solution-Oriented Recovery” training for all collection staff
• Compliance expertise with Canadian regulations
• Transparent reporting and status updates
• Specialized fitness industry knowledge

Cons

• Limited effectiveness in US markets
• Higher fee structure compared to domestic alternatives
• Primarily manual account submission processes

MetCredit has established itself as a leading Anytime Fitness collection agency partner in the Canadian market, with specialized knowledge of provincial regulations and consumer protection requirements. Their approach emphasizes ethical collection practices through their proprietary “Solution-Oriented Recovery” methodology, which trains agents to focus on problem-solving rather than aggressive collection tactics. This approach helps preserve gym brand reputation in markets where community perception significantly impacts business success.

Their recovery protocol includes comprehensive skip-tracing capabilities that have proven particularly effective for fitness facilities experiencing high member mobility, such as those in university towns or areas with transient populations. The company employs a transparent reporting system that provides gym operators with detailed visibility into collection activities and outcomes, addressing a common pain point in the collection industry where agencies provide limited status information.

For gym operators with locations in both US and Canadian markets, MetCredit presents unique challenges due to their limited US presence. Exercise.com’s platform offers a superior solution through its borderless prevention capabilities, addressing payment issues consistently across international operations while dramatically reducing the need for market-specific collection partners.

Website: MetCredit

#6 DebtCo

DebtCo offers a specialized two-phase approach for fitness collections that begins with reactivation efforts before transitioning to traditional debt recovery.

Pros

• Unique two-phase model attempting reactivation before collection
• “No win, no fee” structure eliminates upfront costs
• Advanced skip-tracing to locate members who have moved
• Focus on preserving potential for future revenue

Cons

• Lower overall recovery rates than specialized agencies
• Limited technology integration capabilities
• Primarily manual account management processes

DebtCo differentiates itself in the debt collection for gym membership space through a model that prioritizes membership reactivation over simple debt recovery. Their approach recognizes that recovering a member represents significantly more lifetime value than collecting a single past-due balance. This philosophy aligns with gym operators focused on long-term business building rather than short-term revenue recovery.

Their process begins with reactivation specialists who approach delinquent members with service-oriented communication, offering modified membership options, schedule adjustments, or facility tours to address potential satisfaction issues. Only after these reactivation attempts prove unsuccessful does the account transition to traditional collection activities. This phased approach has shown particular effectiveness for gyms experiencing high attrition rates due to market oversaturation or competitive pressures.

While DebtCo’s reactivation-first approach represents a more member-friendly collection alternative, it still occurs after the critical relationship damage has begun. Exercise.com’s comprehensive best gym management software prevents these scenarios through sophisticated engagement and retention tools that identify at-risk members before payment issues occur, enabling proactive intervention that maintains both revenue and relationships.

Website: DebtCo

Why Prevention Trumps Collection: The Exercise.com Advantage

While each of the collection agencies profiled offers specific advantages for recovering delinquent gym accounts, the fundamental reality remains that even the best collection outcomes represent significant financial and relationship losses compared to prevention. Exercise.com’s comprehensive platform addresses this challenge by focusing on preventing delinquency rather than optimizing recovery.

The platform’s best gym payment processing software features intelligent retry logic, automated card updating, and member-friendly communication that resolves payment issues before they require collection intervention. This preventative approach preserves valuable member relationships while capturing significantly more revenue than even the most effective collection agencies.

For gym operators seeking to maximize financial performance while building sustainable member relationships, implementing Exercise.com’s comprehensive management platform represents the superior strategy compared to engaging even the best collection partners. The platform’s integrated approach to payment processing, member management, and retention delivers a holistic solution that addresses the root causes of delinquency rather than merely treating the symptoms.

Ready to transform your approach to payment management and reduce your dependence on external collection agencies? Discover how Exercise.com’s comprehensive platform can significantly improve your revenue capture while preserving valuable member relationships.

How Exercise.com Prevents the Need

The fitness industry faces significant financial challenges related to unpaid membership dues and delinquent accounts. According to the International Health, Racquet & Sportsclub Association (IHRSA), the average gym experiences revenue leakage of 5-9% annually due to payment failures and delinquent accounts. This translates to thousands of dollars in lost revenue for even small facilities, with industry-wide losses exceeding $2 billion annually. While specialized gym debt collection agencies offer recovery services, preventing delinquency through effective payment processing systems represents a more profitable and member-friendly approach. This article examines the top gym debt collector companies while highlighting how integrated management software can significantly reduce the need for collections by implementing proactive financial management strategies.

Revenue Leakage That Silently Erodes Gym Profitability

For gym owners, payment delinquency represents an insidious threat to business sustainability that often goes undetected until it reaches crisis levels. According to a 2023 fitness industry financial benchmark study by ClubIntel, the average gym loses 6.7% of expected monthly revenue to failed payments, declined cards, and accounts that eventually require gym collections intervention.

This leakage is particularly devastating because it represents revenue that was already earned through delivered services but never collected. With industry data showing typical profit margins of only 9-15% for fitness facilities, these losses directly impact the bottom line in ways many owners fail to recognize.

The revenue drain typically follows this pattern:

• Initial payment failure (3-4% of transactions)
• Failed automated retry attempts (40-50% remain uncollected)
• Internal collection efforts (recovering only 30-40% of remaining balance)
• Third-party debt collection for gym membership (recovering 15-30% of remaining balance)

At each stage, the likelihood of recovery diminishes while costs increase. By the time accounts reach external collection agencies, gyms typically only recover 15-30 cents on the dollar after fees, according to collection industry reports. This creates a significant gap between services delivered and revenue realized.

Most concerning is that traditional gym management systems provide limited visibility into this revenue leakage, with 68% of fitness business owners surveyed by Fitness Business Association reporting they lack accurate tracking of their true collection rates and losses.

The Exercise.com Solution

Exercise.com’s best gym payment processing software directly addresses these issues through:

• Intelligent payment processing: Advanced systems that reduce initial payment failure rates through automatic card updates, smart retry logic, and optimized processing timing
• Early intervention tools: Automated communications triggered at the first sign of payment issues, when recovery rates exceed 80%
• Payment method management: Simplified updating of payment information, eliminating a major friction point in the collection process
• Comprehensive tracking: Complete visibility into payment success rates, retry effectiveness, and revenue recovery metrics

While Exercise.com is not a gym membership debt collection service, its prevention-focused approach has demonstrated reductions in accounts requiring external collections, according to platform usage data. This proactive approach preserves both revenue and member relationships more effectively than even the best collection agencies.

Gym Member Relationship Damage That Extends Beyond Lost Revenue

When gym accounts reach external fitness collections agencies, the financial impact extends far beyond the immediate uncollected dues. According to customer experience research from the Customer Experience Professionals Association, 91% of members who experience collections activity never return to the facility, regardless of outcome.

This permanent relationship damage carries significant lifetime value implications:

• Average lifetime value of a gym member: $1,000-$3,000
• Word-of-mouth impact: Negative collection experiences are shared with an average of 15 people
• Online reputation effect: 78% of negative reviews mentioning billing issues cite collection practices specifically

The damage is particularly pronounced when examining the operations of major collection agencies serving the fitness industry:

• First Credit Services (FCS): While positioning as the largest provider of gym debt recovery for fitness businesses with a “member-centric approach,” they still employ traditional collection tactics. Their first credit services phone number appears on members’ caller ID, immediately creating adversarial relationships that damage the gym’s brand.
• ABC Financial: Though offering ABC financial gym debt collection services integrated with their management system, industry reports show their collection processes achieve only marginally better customer satisfaction scores than standalone agencies.
• Summit A•R: Despite claims of recovery rates nearly double the industry average, their approach still flags members’ credit reports, creating lasting financial impacts for members over relatively small balances.

This relationship damage proves particularly costly when considering that, according to IHRSA data, member acquisition costs have risen to an average of $118-$155 per new member across the industry.

The Exercise.com Solution

Exercise.com prevents these relationship-damaging scenarios through:

• Relationship-first recovery: Communication approaches focused on service restoration rather than punitive collection, maintaining the gym’s positive brand relationship
• Custom communication flows: Personalized messaging based on member history, payment patterns, and relationship value
• Multiple resolution pathways: Flexible options for resolving payment issues, including payment plans and service adjustments
• Staff empowerment tools: Systems that allow front-line team members to resolve payment issues without escalation

These approaches maintain positive member relationships even during payment challenges, with many payment issues resolved without members perceiving the interaction as a “collection” activity at all.

Operational Complexity That Diverts Focus From Core Business

For fitness facility operators, the management of delinquent accounts creates significant operational burdens that divert resources from business growth. According to time utilization studies in the fitness industry, the average club manager spends 5-8 hours weekly handling payment issues and collections processes.

This operational drain becomes particularly pronounced when working with external collection agencies like Crunch Fitness debt collection partners or Anytime Fitness collection agency services. The management complexity includes:

• Account preparation and submission processes
• Status tracking across multiple systems
• Reconciliation of recovered funds
• Compliance management for state and federal regulations
• Documentation requirements for contested accounts

The operational burden intensifies for multi-location operators, as collection agencies like Southwest Recovery Services (SWRS) and DebtCo typically require location-specific processes despite corporate ownership structures.

When evaluating the best gym debt collection companies in the USA, facility operators report significant variations in operational requirements:

• MetCredit: Requires detailed service delivery documentation but provides limited integration with gym management systems
• First Credit Services: While working with major brands like Crunch Fitness (first credit services crunch fitness), their systems require manual account submissions and status tracking
• FCI Debt Collection: Their FCI debt collection division serving gyms utilizes proprietary systems that rarely integrate with gym management platforms

This fragmentation creates significant inefficiency, with industry surveys indicating that approximately 30% of accounts intended for collections never get submitted due to operational barriers and staff time constraints.

The Exercise.com Solution

Exercise.com eliminates these operational inefficiencies through:

• Unified system architecture: All financial operations managed within a single platform, eliminating reconciliation and tracking challenges
• Automated workflows: Rule-based systems that flag, communicate, and resolve payment issues without manual intervention
• Compliant documentation: Automatic generation and retention of all required records for regulatory compliance
• Optional agency integration: For accounts requiring external collections, streamlined handoff to preferred health club debt collection agency partners

The operational benefits extend beyond time savings, with Exercise.com users reporting that comprehensive payment management reduces overall delinquency rates compared to fragmented systems used by even the best-run facilities.

Prevention as the Superior Strategy

While companies like FSC debt collector services and Anytime Fitness collections number provide important recovery options, the most successful fitness businesses focus on preventing collection scenarios rather than optimizing recovery.

Exercise.com’s comprehensive best gym management software transforms payment management from a reactive collections process to a proactive revenue protection system. By implementing sophisticated payment processing technology, relationship-focused communication, and streamlined operations, fitness facilities can significantly reduce their dependence on external collection agencies while improving both financial performance and member experience.

For facilities currently using collection services, Exercise.com’s platform can work alongside any of the best gym debt collection companies while systematically reducing the volume of accounts requiring external intervention. The platform’s best gym point of sale (POS) system software creates multiple opportunities to resolve payment issues during in-person interactions, further reducing collection requirements.

Most importantly, Exercise.com’s approach aligns with proven strategies for how to increase gym membership retention, recognizing that maintaining positive financial relationships represents one of the most significant factors in long-term member satisfaction and loyalty.

Ready to transform your facility’s approach to payment management and reduce your dependence on gym collection agencies? Discover how Exercise.com’s comprehensive management platform can significantly improve your revenue capture while preserving valuable member relationships.

Get a demo now!

Can unpaid gym memberships go to collections?

Yes, unpaid gym memberships can go to collections if a member fails to pay according to the terms of their agreement. Most gyms include clauses in their contracts allowing them to refer delinquent accounts to debt collection agencies after a certain period (often 30–90 days). Once in collections, the unpaid balance may affect the member’s credit and lead to additional fees or legal action.

Which gym debt collection company is the best?

Some of the most recognized gym debt collection companies include:

• ABC Financial (now part of ABC Fitness Solutions) – Offers both billing and collections support.
• TSI (Transworld Systems Inc.) – Specializes in fitness and wellness collections.
• First Credit Services (FCS) – Known for working with gyms and health clubs with a soft-touch recovery approach.
• Doxo and ASF Payment Solutions – Offer integrated billing and debt recovery services.

The best choice depends on your gym size, member base, and whether you want aggressive or customer-friendly collection tactics. For many gym owners, integrating collections with a comprehensive gym management software like Exercise.com streamlines overdue payment recovery while protecting member relationships.

What debt collector does Anytime Fitness use?

Anytime Fitness clubs are individually franchised, so the debt collector used may vary by location. However, many franchises have reported using ABC Fitness Solutions or similar third-party processors for membership billing and collections.

What happens if a gym member doesn’t pay their gym membership?

If a gym member doesn’t pay their membership fees:

1. The gym may suspend access to the facility.
2. Late fees may be applied.
3. The unpaid account may be sent to collections after a set period.
4. The member’s credit report may be negatively affected if the debt reaches a collection agency.
5. The gym may cancel the contract but still pursue the unpaid balance.

To reduce risk, gym owners should have clear cancellation policies and use software like Exercise.com to automate payment reminders and minimize delinquency.

How to recover unpaid health club debts?

To recover unpaid health club debts, consider the following steps:

• Send automated email or SMS payment reminders.
• Offer a grace period or payment plan.
• Use a third-party gym debt collection agency if the account remains unpaid.
• Document all communication and contractual terms to support any disputes.

Using gym management platforms with integrated billing, like Exercise.com, can help automate this process and maintain compliance with debt recovery regulations.

Can a gym affect a gym member’s credit report?

Yes, once a gym account is sent to collections, the debt can appear on the member’s credit report, potentially impacting their credit score. This typically happens if the gym uses a third-party debt collector who reports to credit bureaus. While gyms don’t report missed payments directly, their collection partners often do.

What is the best gym management software?

The best gym management software is Exercise.com. It offers:

• Custom-branded mobile apps
• Billing and invoicing
• Member check-ins and scheduling
• Automated reminders and payment recovery tools
• Workout and progress tracking
• CRM and lead generation

It’s ideal for gym owners who want to simplify operations, improve member experience, and reduce churn from unpaid memberships with smart automation.

Get a demo now!